Learning to Type: We Try Out Four Typing Educational Programs
Typing photos from Unsplash, Monkeytype logo from Monkeytype
So this year I (re)learned how to type.
It all started because I wanted a cute keyboard with cute keycaps. I had lugged around a cheap, hand-me-up Kensington for years. Considering how much I work and play on my computer, I wanted something that would be practical, long-lasting, and easier on my hands. I settled on the Ergodox EZ from keyboard manufacturer ZSA. It’s a tried and true model, originally kickstarted back in 2015 and still getting updates. But exploring ergonomics turned me into the kind of freak that uses an alternative keyboard layout (Graphite in my case).
I could regale you with QWERTY’s inefficiencies or the pleasures of re-learning to type, but the fact is that it is not for the faint of heart. It can be agonizing to suddenly lose a skill that you use every single day. When I started learning Graphite, my WPM dropped from 57 to 13. Within a week or two of dedicated practice, I got up to around 30 WPM. After two months, I was about where I had been before. All told, this is not that much time. But the skill drop-off is so steep, it can feel overwhelming. If you already know how to touch type than you have some of the basic skills. I type everyday for hours, a few weeks of slowness and confusion seemed to be a worthy tradeoff. But I am also a stubborn creature, (sometimes) determined to wade through experience that might seem overwhelming or confusing. I’ve beaten Pathologic 2 twice.
But the thing that made this process bearable was the wide range of typing tools and teaching aids that helped me relearn. Learning a new layout made me appreciate ~educational software~. A computer is something that can teach you how to use it. That is a relatively unique thing in terms of technology (a term we now associate with computers almost entirely). A book or a wheel can’t do that. But the PC is a marvelous device where a program like Mavis Beacon Teaches Typing can show you how to work it. There is a kind of magic in that, a flicker of tech utopianism which the world simultaneously instills in and beats out of me.
So if you’re interested in learning a new layout or just want to practice a skill which you might have taken for granted, here are some of the tools I used to relearn to type.
This was what I used the most in my early days of relearning. The serious advantage of keybr is that it trains one letter at a time. When you are learning a new layout and everything is alien, it is helpful to build a rigorous understanding of home row. With a layout like Graphite, this can have some novelty. It routinely astounds me how little I have to leave home row as I type. Writing entire sets of words with just one row of your keyboard injects a nerdy thrill. However, the longer I trained the more keybr’s usefulness waned. The fact is, unless you are trying to reach truly massive speeds, you don’t need to train z or q very much. You won’t use them often! Additionally, part of typing is the cadence. Long words are often followed by shorter ones. Longer sentences are punctuated with brief stabs at meaning. The premise of keybr means what you’ll often type long words, all with at least one instance of the same letter. That doesn’t really reflect what you will actually be typing in your work or hobbies, even if you are a writer who drops five dollar words causally.
The main reason I dropped keybr, however, was that I found it compulsive. When you start using keybr, you set a target speed that you must hit with a specific letter before you unlock the next one. Getting fractions of WPM closer to unlocking a new letter gave keybr a “one more turn” type compulsion. Furthermore, unlike the other typing tools I’ll discuss in this list, keybr doesn’t exit to a results screen once you finish a drill. This means it is easy to just keep typing. This might be a function of my unusual brain. I sometimes need an off-ramp (or just a good stopping place) out of a program or game. The total lack of one was difficult to resist.
Long story short, I would use keybr to learn home row and then drop it. But your experience might vary from mine.