Volo’s Guide to Monsters isn’t a Typical Dungeons & Dragons Monster Manual

The second section of the book includes statistics and rules for additional races (I always prefer “species” here) that players in your Dungeons & Dragons campaign could roleplay as. Aasimar, kenku, goliaths and a few others make up the thirteen new 5th Edition species. The most I have to say about this is that you should definitely play the kenku. It’s a cool crow-person who hollers and squawks and generally just owns bones all over the Forgotten Realms.

The last third of the book is a more traditional bestiary that you might be familiar with in the form of the many Monster Manuals across the different editions of D&D. It’s a list of monsters, a block of statistics about them, and some basic explanatory segments about how they live in the world. You’re not getting the deep, contextualized information that exists in the opening of Volo’s Guide to Monsters, but these are mostly creatures that don’t need it. The froghemoth, which is “an amphibious predator as big as an elephant,” doesn’t really need a longform explanation of its religious beliefs. It’s a froghemoth. It does what it says on the label.

I will say that the creatures in the Guide are generally more interesting and useful to me as a Dungeon Master than the ones in the original Monster Manual for 5th edition. Those original monsters were staples, but as a DM I could generally figure out what staples were supposed to do on my own. Volo’s Guide has creatures I would never think of, let alone know how to properly “create” in the context of D&D. I would never invent the flail snail, the banderhobb, or the morkoth. They’re all super weird, and I’m glad that this guide book is leaning into those stranger parts of the Forgotten Realms’s ecosystem.

My one serious critique of Volo’s Guide to Monsters is that it doesn’t do enough with its supposed writer. The character Volo has done a number of things: he wrote guides to specific cities, appeared in games, and even wrote the manual for a Baldur’s Gate game. He’s a deeply subjective character who is a bit of a coward, a serious lover of food, and a dude who really likes to talk about himself. He’s got a very specific way of looking at the world, and if I flip open my Volo’s Guide to Waterdeep, I can learn about a tavern in that city called The Misty Beard. “The garlic butter is justly famous, and a wonderful gooseberry jam is made on the premises,” Volo writes. Notice that this is pure opinion without an ounce of claim to fact—Volo likes a jam! Everything in that book is written in that way, and you know that you’re getting a view of the world without any claims to objectivity. Volo’s Guide to Monsters has snippets of info from Volo, but it mostly tells the DM facts about a world, rather than opinions, rumors and suspicions that might be completely unfounded. It’s a small complaint, but I feel like Volo as a character who tells you about one slice of the world might be completely eliminated at this point, and that makes me sad.

In any case, the book is interesting and genuinely helpful for any given Dungeon Master who might be using these monsters in her campaign. It might also be a great gift for any given person who wants to read about interesting world and monster design.

Cameron Kunzelman tweets at @ckunzelman and writes about games at thiscageisworms.com. His latest game, Epanalepsis, was released last year. It’s available on Steam.