GrimGrimoire‘s Spellbinding Remaster Is a Testament of Vanillaware’s Growth

By Austin Jones | April 28, 2023 | 12:23pm

Video Games Features GrimGrimoire

GrimGrimoire‘s Spellbinding Remaster Is a Testament of Vanillaware’s Growth

Vanillaware has always been a group of misfits. Formed in 2002 by George Kamitani, his Starcraft buddy Kentaro Ohnishi, and doujin developer Shigetake, the goal of Vanillaware was to make games on their own terms, freely experimenting and taking inspiration from RTSes, beat-em-ups, and the Atelier series. Kamitani previously had negative working relationships with both Sega and Enix (who were in the midst of their merger with Square), effectively blacklisting him and his future projects from being anything but self-produced. After the trio’s frustrated experience working on Square Enix’s MMO Fantasy Earth: The Ring of Dominion, they corralled former Atlus employees to work on Odin Sphere, Kamitani’s white whale that was intended as a spiritual successor to Princess Crown, the game that nearly ruined his career.

Though Odin Sphere was their first project and the entire reason for Vanillaware’s inception, GrimGrimoire was their first actual release. GrimGrimoire was a commission from Nippon Ichi Software’s then president Sohei Shinkawa, who, being a fan of Princess Crown, essentially gave Kamitani complete creative control to produce whatever he wanted. Vanillaware united over their already established love of Starcraft to craft a short, stylish, and mechanically deep console RTS, a genre that has almost always made its home on PCs. They would have to make an entirely new type of RTS, one that could not be so easily compared to its keyboard-and-mouse cousins.

GrimGrimoire takes place in a whimsical, sweetly gothic world of magic and spells. Instead of building tanks or recruiting vikings, the player takes on the role of a novice magician named Lillet Blan, who can summon fairies, ghosts, and demons with runes. GrimGrimoire doesn’t have a top-down aesthetic, nor does it have a way to accelerate time. Instead, GrimGrimoire is structured as a series of visual novel segments that lead into discrete levels, viewed horizontally, where you have an explicit goal, such as annihilating all an enemy’s runes or surviving a 20 minute onslaught. Though your options are limited when compared to a game like Starcraft, the brevity of each level and complex stacking of match-ups and abilities between summonable familiars means you can approach each level differently, replay them to find more efficient means to succeed, and experiment with options as you go.

Most Popular

Like Odin Sphere, GrimGrimoire had its noticeable flaws at release. Common criticisms were leveraged against the game’s basic interfacing, which were seen as clunky given the restrictions of using a controller or the lack of saving mid-battle. Others found the battles grew repetitive given the lack of variation once you have every grimoire unlocked. Unlike Odin Sphere, though, GrimGrimoire underperformed and led to Kamitani having to take out a sizable personal loan to save Vanillaware. On paper, GrimGrimoire was a failure. But it also led directly to Vanillaware’s greatest success.

Originally, GrimGrimoire was planned to be divided down the middle into adventure game segments with full exploration and the RTS levels that were eventually included. Due to time and money constraints, the game took on a more visual novel-esque shape, which, while gorgeously rendered, does limit the scope of the game considerably. This would be an idea Vanillaware would revisit over a decade later. Perhaps due to Odin Sphere’s success, Vanillaware leaned into RPG/beat-em-up hybrids over the next several years, such as the Wii game Muramasa: The Demon Blade and the arcade-y multiplayer side-scroller Dragon’s Crown (which was heavily inspired by Dungeons & Dragons: Towers of Doom, which Kamitani himself worked on). They found some success and notoriety in doing so, but their games have always been sleeper hits—Dragon’s Crown didn’t sell its millionth unit until 2017, four years after its initial release.

Amid the production of Dragon’s Crown Pro, the expanded rerelease of the game, Vanillaware began working on a revisitation to their original concepts in GrimGrimoire for their most ambitious project yet: a nonlinear adventure game inspired by speculative fiction, Western conspiracy thrillers, shoujo manga, and Japanese post-war history. This game would be known as 13 Sentinels: Aegis Rim, and would take over five years of development to complete. It may not look it at first glance, but 13 Sentinels was made from the bones of GrimGrimoire. “The original version of GrimGrimoire was remade into 13 Sentinels: Aegis Rim,” Kamitani told Siliconera. The kinship between 13 Sentinels and GrimGrimoire doesn’t end there, though; much of what they learned from 13 Sentinels’s success was incorporated in GrimGrimoire OnceMore, the game’s recent remaster.

Vanillaware are no strangers to learning from their mistakes and using their experience to improve upon previous ideas. Odin Sphere was meant as this for Princess Crown, and its remaster, Odin Sphere Leifthrasir, is almost an entirely different experience because of massive changes to the gameplay and quality of life. For OnceMore, Vanillaware decided to lean into their original ideas for the game and restore elements they did not have the time or budget for 15 years ago.

Besides obvious graphical improvements, OnceMore includes a skill tree for each of your grimoires, which functions on a currency system. After each battle, you get coins that can be spent as you wish on these abilities, which range from new actions familiars can take to passive buffs like starting battles with more mana. Each story mission also includes an additional bonus objective to obtain more coins, which are often added difficulty checks for each level; you might not be able to harvest mana from more than one crystal, or you may be limited to only using certain familiars. OnceMore also makes the game’s bonus missions available much earlier, with the added bonus of gaining coins from completing them. Once coins are spent, you can refund them to lose the ability and get all your coins back so you can experiment with different builds.

This is the most massive change to the core gameplay of OnceMore, but other additions demonstrably alter the experience for the better as well. A new “Grand Magic” command allows certain single use effects such as rewinding time to an earlier checkpoint or doing a large amount of Area of Effect damage. A fast forward option was added, meaning you don’t have to idly watch as your Skullmages slowly tiptoe halfway across the map. And, serendipitously, the expanded aspect ratio allows for a greater field of vision that makes battles feel less overwhelming and cheap.

GrimGrimoire is still not a perfect game, but I am confident that Vanillaware makes the best remasters of any developer. They are a company that constantly wishes to hone in on the core concepts they initially came together to celebrate, and it shows within their dedication to their own history. OnceMore itself only exists because its director, Yoshio Nishimura, loved the game so much and pushed Nippon Ichi for permission and the funds to work on it. A common source of discourse over the last few years has been the death of mid-budget developers who boldly championed high risk, low profit passion projects in the ‘90s and 2000s. Vanillaware may be one of the final remnants of this era, and a developer that should be dearly cherished because of it.

Austin Jones is a writer with eclectic media interests. You can chat with him about horror games, electronic music, Joanna Newsom and ‘80s-‘90s anime on Twitter @belfryfire